The Objective is to ultimately create “San

       Juan National Park

 

-        The Sierra Club started a campaign to create the National Park in the early 1990s with a National Geographic article on the 10 Places That Need to Become National Parks – San Juan backcountry heavily featured.

-        The E.P.A. details Federal employees to work for Trout Unlimited while on Federal payroll – witness Carroll Russell working for Trout Unlimited for approximately 2 years

-        The pattern of creating wilderness areas around Silverton is consistent with the plan to create a National Park.

-        A source in the Interior Department corrected an inquiry six years ago when asked about the plan to create a National Park – “The plan is to create a National Monument like the Black Canyon of the Gunnison first and then go for National Park status later.”

-        A National Conservation Area is the prelude to creating a National Monument

-        Trout Unlimited is the “front” organization to advance the ultimate aim of a National Park – at least be honest about the process! It is not about fishing or recreation. This is not a “grassroots” or “sportsmen-led” effort.

 

You will no longer be able to afford to live in Silverton

 

-        The Federal Government has an active campaign to acquire private mining claims in San Juan County (witness Standard Metals and Asarco having ownership of their lands taken from them).

-        Additional Federal ownership of land collapses San Juan County’s tax base, thereby increasing the tax load in Silverton to the point whereby you can’t afford taxes on your home and must sell. Newcomers who can afford the taxes take over your home.

-        The private mining claims in San Juan County pay a huge amount of taxes which support many of the services used by recreational visitors

 

In fact, your activities will even be curtailed outside the Park’s boundaries

 

-        The National Park Service will pretty much control a lot of the aspects of your life such as the granting of building permits in Silverton, what architectural styles are acceptable, etc. one example is the National Park Service tried to stop a veterinarian building a clinic on his family farm one mile outside of Cuyahoga National Park (outside of Cleveland)

-        The National Park Service will arrest people for every petty infraction such as removing rocks ( in a famous case in Utah, a fellow was rock hounding 300 feet outside the boundaries of Capitol Reef National Park. He was charged with felonies, it was claimed he had done $25,000 of damage using a pick and shovel, and he was outside the boundaries of the park!). It is already against the law to pick up antlers from BLM land, and to pick up a migratory bird feather from any land whatsoever.

-        Access will be cut off.  Some national parks only allow access by NPS tour vehicle.  For those of you who like to snowboard, the BLM is already cutting off access – witness the closure of the road into Ross Basin that you use to snowboard the face of Ross Basin. Snowmobilers will probably be limited to licensed outfitters such as in Yellowstone – and you can bet that no local businesspeople now will be licensed.

 

Our recreational, multi use access works wonderfully now! Many of the recreational activities you enjoy today will be prohibited in a national park.

 

-        One of the beauties of Silverton is that you can camp in the backcountry without a permit, the private land owners work with the county to allow people to enjoy the part of the country we all treasure. There is the ability for all visitors to enjoy the San Juans now. If it ain’t broke, don’t “fix” it.

-        Trout Unlimited says that ATV use won’t be affected.  Don’t believe them. This will be one of the first things to go in the National Park process. Hunters will be somewhere in the line to be banned.

-        The BLM is already trying to get a $100,000 fine for anyone who inadvertently “damages” BLM land (such as driving around a bog on the road or grading a road not knowing the BLM owns 10 feet of it).  If the Trout Unlimited proposal goes through, heavy fines for all “infractions” in a National Conservation Area will occur.  That road you have used for 25 years – it won’t be an official road (witness Ross Basin) and you will have a huge fine.

 

 

The U.S. needs the mineral resources in this area, for example to manufacture solar panels, for national defense, and to keep the dollar strong

 

-        The San Juan backcountry has $3 billion+ in minerals known in the mines, and $10+ billion more as a resource base. Generously valuing the “fishing/hunting” improvements at $50 million over the next 100 years offers no comparison.  We already hunt and fish freely.

-        The San Juan backcountry is one of the most highly mineralized areas in the United States.  This is why it was set aside for mining purposes. Not everything in the West should be a national park.

-        Do you like solar power?  If you do, you need to keep the ability to mine in the San Juans.  We have some of the highest indium grades in the world and the San Juan Mountains contains America’s strategic indium resource.  Indium is essential to solar panels and LCD screens.  China controls 90% of the world indium supply.

-        There are significant undiscovered major mineral deposits in the

San Juan backcountry. San Juan County contains a large strategic mineral element resource.

-        New mines are intensively environmentally regulated. They are the most intensively monitored in the world.

-        The 8,400 tons of gold supposedly held by the Federal Government in Fort Knox is long gone.  Gold industry experts believe that the U.S. Government owes an additional 3,000 tons+ of gold to the world markets.  This gold will have to be replaced. The San Juan backcountry has some of the highest grade gold deposits in the country. Our country will need the gold production from San Juan County.

-        Keeping the ability to mine in the San Juans is essential to the national defense of the United States and the economy of the United States.  Trying to destroy the ability to mine in the San Juans is to destroy the backup ability of the U.S. to supply critical elements to its economy and defense forces.  Do you want to sell out what’s left of your country?

 

Fairness to current property owners is the last thing Trout Unlimited or the Department of the Interior care about

 

-        You cannot operate a mine without access to the BLM lands.  You have to travel over BLM land via roads that need to be maintained, the ore deposits stretch beyond the patented claim lines, and you cannot situate a mine waste rock pile without going beyond the 300 foot width of a patented mining claim. Trout Unlimited, the Sierra Club and the National Park Service know this. The statement that property owners will still be able to mine and “enjoy” their lands is fictitious.  Some families have owned their patented mining claims for a hundred years, and the value will be taken away from them.

 

 

The best potential for high paying, local jobs will be destroyed.  The best potential for significant local tax revenues will be destroyed.

 

-        Mining jobs pay $50,000 to $70,000 per year.  A mine will normally employ 30 to 200 persons.  Contrast this with the 100 day a year tourist economy. Someone working for $8.50 an hour in the one fly fishing shop to open will not compensate the loss of these potential jobs. Plus, each mining job creates two to three other year round jobs in the community.

-        Gold prices are expected to crest at $2500 plus per ounce. We will have good mining jobs here in the future, jobs which allow people to raise families in Silverton, to send children to college and to have nice things.  Trout Unlimited’s proposal keeps us in the poverty loop. We do have a significant proportion of our school children in need or some form of need.

-        Two mines alone have 670,000 ounces of gold delineated in them.  At $1100 per ounce, that is $740 million. Think of what this will do for the economy in Silverton when they are operated. The tax revenues generated will provide the services and help for our school district that San Juan County needs.

 

Durango may benefit, but Silverton will not

 

-        Working to ultimately create a national park at Silverton will benefit the economy of Durango.

-        What is the lives of 500 people in Silverton and the landowners in San Juan County when you can have your property in Durango go up in value?

 

If you have nothing to lose and the potential to gain, it’s easy to back an idea that means taking the homes, property and recreational rights of others

 

-        How much land does Ty Churchwell or any of the other Trout Unlimited people own in the San Juan backcountry?  It is easy to take away 186,000 acres of land when you don’t own any.